how to get an analytical solution
16 vues (au cours des 30 derniers jours)
Afficher commentaires plus anciens
Darcy Chou
le 26 Juin 2018
Commenté : Ameer Hamza
le 26 Juin 2018
syms tp t
NN=((exp(-1.45*10^(-4)*tp^1.274))^1.5)/2
z=4/3*pi*NN*(t-tp)^3
Z=int(z,tp,0,t)
output is
Z =
int((2*pi*exp(-(2674777890687885*tp^(637/500))/18446744073709551616)^(3/2)*(t - tp)^3)/3, tp, 0, t)
that is not an analytical solution, then how can I get the analytical solution?
If t=10 ,how to get the numerical solution?
Thanks for reading.
1 commentaire
Walter Roberson
le 26 Juin 2018
You cannot expect analytic solutions when you use exponents that are floating point numbers, as calculus does not define integrals with floating point exponents.
You should not be asking for an analytic integral for any expression that involves any floating point constants at all. If you want to express uncertainty in value (floating point values need to be considered as uncertain) then replace the floating point numbers with rationals plus a symbolic uncertainty.
Réponse acceptée
Ameer Hamza
le 26 Juin 2018
The existence of an analytical solution is not always necessary. I cannot prove mathematically but it might be the case that this function does not have an analytical solution at all. It might also be the limitation of MATLAB symbolic engine. In the first case, there is not much you can do other than resorting to the numerical solution. In the second case, you may try some other symbolic math engine. As far as the numerical result is concerned, you can get it as with integral().
syms tp t
NN=((exp(-1.45*10^(-4)*tp^1.274))^1.5)/2;
z=4/3*pi*NN*(t-tp)^3;
Z=int(z,tp,0,t);
Z_function = matlabFunction(z);
Z_numerical = integral(@(tp) Z_function(10, tp), 0, 10);
2 commentaires
Plus de réponses (2)
KSSV
le 26 Juin 2018
syms tp t
NN=((exp(-1.45*10^(-4)*tp^1.274))^1.5)/2 ;
z=4/3*pi*NN*(t-tp)^3 ;
Z=int(z,0,t)
subs(Z,'t',10)
4 commentaires
Walter Roberson
le 26 Juin 2018
No, the syntax
Z=int(z,tp,0,t)
means integrate z(tp) over tp = 0 to tp = t . tp is not a constant in the integral.
t might be a constant, but tp is not.
Walter Roberson
le 26 Juin 2018
You have
NN=((exp(-1.45*10^(-4)*tp^1.274))^1.5)/2
Remember that exp(A*x)^B is the same as exp(A*B*x), so you can bring the 1.5 inside, forming
NN=exp(-1.5*1.45*10^(-4)*tp^1.274)/2
Now introduce a symbolic variable A and rewrite this as
syms tp nonnegative
syms A positive
NN = exp(-A*tp^sym(1.274)) / 2
for A = 1.5*1.45*10^(-4) but leave A as symbolic at the moment.
Then look at
z=4/3*pi*NN*(t-tp)^3
and see that this can be rewritten as
z = B * exp(-A*tp^sym(1.274)) * (t-tp)^3
for B = 4/3*pi/2
Now you want int(z, tp, 0, t)
which is int(B * exp(-A*tp^sym(1.274)) * (t-tp)^3, tp, 0, t)
which is B * int(exp(-A*tp^sym(1.274)) * (t-tp)^3, tp, 0, t)
And it turns out that MATLAB can calculate
temp = int(exp(-A*tp^sym(1.274)) * (t-tp)^3, tp, 0, t)
fairly quickly.
So the overall result is 4/3*pi/2 * subs(temp, A, 1.5*1.45*10^(-4))
3 commentaires
Walter Roberson
le 26 Juin 2018
Oooo... I just discovered that I had a bracket in the wrong place when I was doing the int(). MATLAB cannot calculate temp easily after all :(
Ameer Hamza
le 26 Juin 2018
int(exp(A*tp^1.274)*(t-tp)^3, tp)
in term of gamma function. Although gamma function is itself defined in term of an integral for most cases.
I cannot find the required definite integral because its calculation requires a pro license. But I guess maple or Mathematica might be able to give a solution for the definite integral. Although I am not sure whether such a solution will be useful for any practical purpose.
Also from @Darcy comment, it appears that the result will later be used in a numerical optimization problem. Since you are eventually using a numerical optimization algorithm, it might be better to also use numerical integration techniques instead of searching for a closed form solution.
Voir également
Catégories
En savoir plus sur Calculus dans Help Center et File Exchange
Community Treasure Hunt
Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!
Start Hunting!