Two different bode plots same circuit

I have the circuit attached that I am currently working on. I derived the equations for Vout/V2 and I arrived with the plot on the RHS. I run the model in simulink to confirm this and I am getting two different bode plots. I have worked on this for two days. I am not seeing what the problem. I am pretty sure this is easy fix. More than likely I am just overlooking something simple.