How to change output format from solve function

25 vues (au cours des 30 derniers jours)
Quentin Dragomir
Quentin Dragomir le 12 Nov 2020
Hello,
I would like to change the output format from the solve equation.
For instance in this simple example:
syms d
dist = solve(115.7==20*log10(4*pi*d/lambda)-10*log10(Gr)-10*log10(Ge)-2.2,d)
I get as answer:
dist = 10^(691379199349428923/112589990684262400)/(24*pi)
What command could I use to receive
dist = 1.8337e+04
Thanks you.

Réponse acceptée

Stephan
Stephan le 12 Nov 2020

Plus de réponses (1)

Walter Roberson
Walter Roberson le 12 Nov 2020
Your use of 115.7 and 2.2 in the equation tells us that you are working with values that are fundamentally not exact. 115.7 here expresses "some indeterminate value that is between 11565/100 (inclusive) and 11575/100 (exclusive)" . As such it does not make sense to ask for an exact solution. solve() is for use in cases where you want indefinitely precise solutions, which is not the case here. You should be using vpasolve() instead.
If for some reason you believe that 115.7 is exactly 1157/10 then you should be using
syms d
Q = @(v) sym(V); %convert to symbolic algebraic number
dist = solve( Q(115.7) == Q(20)*log10(Q(4)*Q(pi)*d/lambda) - Q(10)*log10(Gr)-Q(10)*log10(Ge)-Q(2.2), d)
... and expect an exact solution formula. Which you could then vpa() or double() to see an approximation of.
The calls to Q() there are to convert floating point numbers into the closest algebraic number (or into Pi), such as 115.7 -> 1157/10 and 1.4142135623731 -> 2^(1/2)
  1 commentaire
Quentin Dragomir
Quentin Dragomir le 12 Nov 2020
I'm not sure to understand the differences between solve and vpasolve.
I could rewritte my equation to have :
dist = solve(117.9==20*log10(4*pi*d/lambda)-10*log10(Gr)-10*log10(Ge),d)
Here I should obtain an exact solution

Connectez-vous pour commenter.

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by