Symbolic integration vs numerical integration
38 views (last 30 days)
Show older comments
I have an expression with three variables x,y and v. I want to symbolically integrate v, and so I use int function
The command that I use is the following:
v =int((1-fxyz)*pv, v, y,+inf)% Its is taking too long for it to compute symbolically what do I do
Are there tricks to make int compute faster?
PS I havent given you what the function fxyv is but it is very complicated.
I know one option for me is to integrate numerically using for example integrate, however I want to note that the second part of this problem requires me to integrate g(x,y) over x and y from 0 to infinity. So I can't take numerical values of x and y when I want to integrate over v I think or maybe not ?
Mike Hosea on 1 Feb 2015
Edited: Mike Hosea on 1 Feb 2015
It's likely to be quite slow, but it may be possible to take this on numerically. For performance reasons MATLAB insists that integrands be "vectorized", i.e. capable of accepting arrays of inputs and returning arrays of outputs, so we will need to address this. First let me assume that f and p are not coded in a way that would permit me to pass in an array and expect them to return an array of the same size.
gscalar = @(x,y)integral(@(v)arrayfun(@(v)(1 - f(x,y,v)).*p(v),v),y,inf);
g = @(x,y)arrayfun(gscalar,x,y);
T = integral2(@(x,y)exp(g(x,y)),0,inf,@(x)x,inf)
First we defined a gscalar function that accepts scalar x and y and evaluates the innermost integral. Then we used arrayfun to "vectorize" the gscalar function, creating a function that could accept arrays of x and y values and calculates the integrals element-wise. Finally integral2 calculates the outer double integral.
You can tack on 'AbsTol' and 'RelTol' arguments to the integral and integral2 calls.
In case you (or someone reading this) are not familiary with arrayfun, arrayfun is a "loop in a box" sort of thing. Think of
z = arrayfun(f,x,y)
as if it were
z = zeros(size(x));
for k = 1:numel(z)
z(k) = f(x(k),y(k));
but arrayfun should be faster than writing the loop in MATLAB.
You might be able to drop the use of arrayfun in the definition of gscalar if f and p are coded in such a way that they can handle an array of v inputs combined with scalar x and y inputs and deliver the correct value.
More Answers (1)
Susan on 14 Feb 2019
Could you please help me with this integral? TIA!!!!
a = 0 :10 and x = sqrt(2*a) and the goal is plotting Pb versus x(expresses in decibels (dB)).
Find more on Logical in Help Center and File Exchange
Community Treasure Hunt
Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!Start Hunting!