Effacer les filtres
Effacer les filtres

parpool sorting out the default number of workers

46 vues (au cours des 30 derniers jours)
Bruno Luong
Bruno Luong le 5 Jan 2023
Déplacé(e) : Bruno Luong le 31 Jan 2023
I'm a little bit lost in the default number of workers when parpool() is invoked. My PC is standalone with Intel Processor and Windows-based with MATLAB R200B.
  • In the Preferences Parallel Computing Toolbox window, both Porcesses and Threads profiles indicate the default value of number of workers is 12
  • My processor has 14 cores; 6 performance, 6 Efficient, and 20 (hyper) threading according to Intel link
The command maxNumCompThreads returns 6
>> maxNumCompThreads('automatic')
ans =
6
The command parpool returns 14
>> delete(gcp('nocreate'))
>> p = parpool('Threads')
Starting parallel pool (parpool) using the 'Threads' profile ...
Connected to the parallel pool (number of workers: 14).
p =
ThreadPool with properties:
NumWorkers: 14
Busy: false
The questions are
  • Why 14 and not 12 as setup by Preferences?
  • How parpool and Preferences setup those numbers?
In general it's all over the place to me, if someone can shed the light it would be great.

Réponse acceptée

Alison Eele
Alison Eele le 31 Jan 2023
Déplacé(e) : Bruno Luong le 31 Jan 2023
Thanks for the follow on questions Bruno!
Preferred Number of Workers in a Pool
For parpool('processes') the number of workers you will get will be the minimum of: the parallel preference; or the NumWorkers field in the 'processes' cluster profile. In your case I would expect it to open a parallel pool of 12 workers [min(12,14)].
The default value of 12 in the Parallel Preferences will only apply to non-thread pools. This stems from Thread pools historically following the value of maxNumCompThreads() thus this preference never applied. From R2022b you can now specify a size of thread pool and parpool('threads') defers to the same default number of workers as the 'processes' profile i.e. the number of physical cores detected.
maxNumCompThreads behaviour
The value returned by maxNumCompThreads('automatic') is counting just your performance cores (6) rather than performance + efficiency (14). This is because maxNumCompThreads primarily focuses on the implicit multi-threading of mathematical operations which should take place on the Performance cores of your processor. Adding additional threads would either cause resource contention on the Performance cores or cause them to run on some of the efficiency cores which could incur some slowdown on the overall operation.
Standalone Deployed Application
When you deploy onto another machine using the 'processes' or 'local' profile it by default will use a number of cores = to the number of physical cores detected on the machine. I would recommend finding out how many workers the cluster profile thinks it has by instantiating a cluster object then querying the number of workers:
c = parcluster('processes');
numcores = c.NumWorkers
This would be safer than using an undocumented feature command.
  1 commentaire
Bruno Luong
Bruno Luong le 31 Jan 2023
Déplacé(e) : Bruno Luong le 31 Jan 2023
Many thanks @Alison Eele for clearing hings out.

Connectez-vous pour commenter.

Plus de réponses (1)

Raymond Norris
Raymond Norris le 6 Jan 2023
Modifié(e) : Edric Ellis le 6 Jan 2023
Hey @Bruno Luong, per your link, you have 8 Efficient cores, hence 14 (6+8) cores. For R2022b (which I think is the version you're using), the Threads profile doesn't allow for less than the number of cores you have. The Process profile uses the standard min(12,#cores).
For Performance vs Efficient, can you run the following and post the answer?
feature numcores
  2 commentaires
Edric Ellis
Edric Ellis le 6 Jan 2023
There was a typo in @Raymond Norris's code (which I'll correct) - feature numcores is the thing.
Bruno Luong
Bruno Luong le 6 Jan 2023
Modifié(e) : Bruno Luong le 6 Jan 2023
Thanks.
>> feature numcores
MATLAB detected: 14 physical cores.
MATLAB detected: 20 logical cores.
MATLAB was assigned: 20 logical cores by the OS.
MATLAB is using: 14 logical cores.
MATLAB is not using all logical cores because hyper-threading is enabled.
ans =
14
So can I conclude
  • the default value (12) in the preference GUI of the Threads/Proceeses profile is ignored by parpool?
  • What is the value returned by maxNumCompThreads('automatic') (6)?
  • If I deploy a standalone application via MATLAB compiler toolbox on another platform what command should I use then to get a right number of cores for proper configuring parpool (I don't want the default value since there are other apps runing in concurrent with MATLAB)? I tend to use this:
numcores = feature('numcores')

Connectez-vous pour commenter.

Catégories

En savoir plus sur Parallel Computing Fundamentals dans Help Center et File Exchange

Produits


Version

R2022b

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by