Effacer les filtres
Effacer les filtres

Draw samples using a Non-Gaussian distribution

19 vues (au cours des 30 derniers jours)
user20912 le 18 Sep 2023
Modifié(e) : Bruno Luong le 19 Sep 2023
Let's say I have a vector X of 100 values. How can I draw a sample from this vector using a Non-Gaussian distribution?
Consider the following example in which I'm trying to draw 50 values from the original vector:
x = randn(100,1);
Array indices must be positive integers or logical values.
Here, the Poisson distribution is just an example. This does not work because of the values I got from the random distribution are not always positive integers or logical values.
Any advice?
  5 commentaires
user20912 le 19 Sep 2023
Your interpretation is correct. I express myself in a poor way, my apologies.
Paul le 19 Sep 2023
So you have a discrete random variable N. Its probability distribution function is P(N = n) = p(n) for n = 1:100, and 0 otherwise. As must be the case, sum(p) = 1.
Do you know the distribution function, i.e., the values of p(n), n = 1:100?
Once you define the distribution function, you want to generate 50 samples of N. Are those samples to be generated with or without replacement? The former is straightforward based on the distribution function. The latter would involve reconditioning p(n) after each selection, but also doesn't sound too bad.

Connectez-vous pour commenter.

Réponse acceptée

Image Analyst
Image Analyst le 18 Sep 2023
Let's say you have a vector of 100 numbers. The numbers could be anything -- doesn't matter, and we don't care. To make x from rand (uniform) or randn (normal distribution) just serves to confuse the issue with another, unrelated distribution. Let's just say that you have x and it is whatever it is and how you got it doesn't matter at all.
Now let's say you have a Normal distribution with a mean of 60 and a standard deviation of 10. So does that mean you would draw indexes in the range 60 +/- 10, in other words you'd pick indexes from about 50 to 70 from the vector? If not, please clarify.
OK, so now let's say you do not want a Gaussian distribution. Does that mean you don't want indexes from 50-70, but want indexes ranging from 1 to 100 (which would be a uniform distribution), or indexes drawn from some other distribution (like Poisson, log normal, Rayleigh, or some other known distribution)?
If you want to get the indexes of x from some arbitrary, but known, distribution, you can use random to get samples drawn from dozens of commonly used distribution functions. If you get floating point numbers, then scale them from 1 to 100 using rescale and then round them so they can be used as indexes. If you have some custom distribution, then you can use Inverse Transform Sampling ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inverse_transform_sampling ) to get some numbers drawn from your custom distribution. See the attached demo for how I used inverse transform sampling to get numbers drawn from a Rayleigh distribution.
Finally, is this your homework, or just something you're curious about?
  1 commentaire
user20912 le 19 Sep 2023
Thanks for your answer. I'm trying to understand the central limit theorem. So esentially, what I have in mind was:
1) Generate a vector, uniform, normal or whatever. As you said, I just happen to have this vector since is not important.
2) Draw a sub-sample of this vector based on a probability density function which were not Gaussian, whatever this could be. I just select Poisson, from the random function, because only requiere one parameter and it was different than Gaussian. Maybe I used in a wrong way, honestly, I don't know.
3) Compute some parameters of this sub-sample such as mean and variance.
So, you answered exactly what I was thinking about:
If you want to get the indexes of x from some arbitrary, but known, distribution, you can use random to get samples drawn from dozens of commonly used distribution functions. If you get floating point numbers, then scale them from 1 to 100 using rescale and then round them so they can be used as indexes
Again, thanks for the help and the clarification.

Connectez-vous pour commenter.

Plus de réponses (3)

Matt J
Matt J le 18 Sep 2023
Modifié(e) : Matt J le 18 Sep 2023
x = randn(100,1);
ans = 50×1
0.1017 -1.1903 -0.6332 0.9512 0.9023 0.0446 0.0218 -0.2012 2.2907 -0.4517
  10 commentaires
Torsten le 18 Sep 2023
Modifié(e) : Torsten le 18 Sep 2023
I've never seen examples of a distribution on a measure space that depends on a sample size of realizations. But maybe your guess is correct and the OP just wants to use "randperm".
user20912 le 19 Sep 2023
Your discussion helped me to clarify some concepts that, as Matt said, I had misunderstood.

Connectez-vous pour commenter.

John D'Errico
John D'Errico le 18 Sep 2023
I think you don't understand random numbers, AND you don't understand indexing in MATLAB. What does this do?
ans = 1×50
2 2 2 4 8 2 10 14 10 14 11 20 10 17 14 9 20 19 22 19 20 18 23 21 27 37 28 23 35 16
It generates a list of 50 Poisson random numbers, with 50 different rate parameters, the numbers 1:50. I have absolutely no idea why you would want to do that.
And worse, some of those Poisson samples will be ZERO. Some might even be larger than 100.
Then you are trying to index into a vector of length 100 using those Poisson samples. The result is? Garbage, since you will often see an indexing error.
Finally, the resulting sample? It will have the same underlying distribution as your original vector x, since you are just sampling from the original vector.
What you mean about a non-Gaussian sample? Using a Poisson distribution there is meaningless.
I think you just want to sample from the vector x. For example, suppose you have a vector of prime numbers. They certainly are not Gaussian, or even uniform.
x = primes(100)
x = 1×25
2 3 5 7 11 13 17 19 23 29 31 37 41 43 47 53 59 61 67 71 73 79 83 89 97
Now we can sample from that set.
nx = numel(x);
This will be a sample WITH replacement. So some elements may be replicated.
ans = 1×10
53 41 97 19 7 79 31 19 43 79
Sampling without replacement is as easy.
ans = 1×10
71 41 17 97 7 79 23 59 11 67
Be careful, as sampling without replacement is not possible, if you want to sample more than 25 elements from a vector of length 25. (Why do I feel this should be both unecessary to say, as well as totally necessary on this forum?)
  3 commentaires
John D'Errico
John D'Errico le 18 Sep 2023
Modifié(e) : John D'Errico le 18 Sep 2023
@torsten: I'm sorry, but it is NOT wrong. It does matter how you sample, of course. So I might give you credit for misunderstanding my statement.
If the index operation has no connection to the samples themselves, then a random sampling from that set does not change the distribution of the sample. That is EXACTLY what was done by the OP.
For example, suppose I have a very simple set:
x = rand(1,5);
the vector x is statistically uniformly distributed, on the interval [0,1]. Now, choose 3 elements from that set, also randomly chosen.
y = x(randperm(5,3));
The vector y WILL be just as uniformly distributed on the interval [0,1], as was the vector x. Can you do things that are not what I was talking about, but are a bit silly? Yes.
z = x(ones(1,1000));
Then z is just a random number, with uniform distribution on the interval [0,1], but then repeated 1000 times. We could split hairs about the distribution of z, but that seems meaningless to me, and was not in the spirit of what I was saying.
Or, if you create y, by selectively sampling more often from the elements of x that are less than 1/2, or something equally silly, then of course it will change things.
Torsten le 18 Sep 2023
Modifié(e) : Torsten le 18 Sep 2023
z = x(ones(1,1000));
z is dirac_x(1) distributed.
As far as I understood, that's an extreme case for what the OP aims at: x(distribution(1:50)) where "distribution" can be any distribution defined on the set {1,2,...,100}. So indices (unlike for randperm) will most probably repeat.

Connectez-vous pour commenter.

Bruno Luong
Bruno Luong le 19 Sep 2023
Modifié(e) : Bruno Luong le 19 Sep 2023
x = rand(1,10000); % whatever, randn(1,100) in your case
n = 5000; % number of drawing 50 in your case
% Set up wanted drawing probability
ix = 1:numel(x);
lambda = 60;
p = poisspdf(ix,lambda);
% generate index according to the above discrete pdf
c = cumsum([0 p]);
c = c/c(end);
rix = discretize(rand(1,n), c);
% Check graphically what the drawing pdf looks like
current_xlim = xlim;
% Compare with the prescribed pdf, it looks OK
hold on
plot(ix, p, '-+', 'Linewidth', 2);
title('This is truncated poisson pdf')
% draw randomy from x (with replacement) with the above pdf
rx = x(rix)
rx = 1×5000
0.1844 0.4804 0.7231 0.6603 0.0501 0.2910 0.5988 0.1482 0.5782 0.9062 0.2965 0.2509 0.5782 0.4804 0.1844 0.1709 0.4665 0.2965 0.5084 0.4335 0.2752 0.1482 0.4802 0.4920 0.4804 0.6473 0.6447 0.2910 0.1844 0.6543
% how it looks like, still random like
% histogram(x)




Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by