Problem with precision in trigonometric functions

13 vues (au cours des 30 derniers jours)
bradzik
bradzik le 26 Oct 2016
Modifié(e) : Jan le 26 Oct 2016
I am encountering problem with converting coordinates from geographic (GCS) to cartesian coordinate system (CCS) and vice versa. Below is my code, if you run it you will see that there is a loss of precision during two conversions. I'm starting with a point P in CCS, converting it to GCS and then back to CCS. As a result I am getting a bit different coordinates from initial point P coordinates. Moreover the result differs depending on the trigonometric functions used. The error seems small but it causes a significant difference in position calculated by trillateration. Is there any way to convert such coordinates with greater precision i Matlab?
% cartesian coordinates of point P
P = [3554.6 ; 1205.7 ; 5150.9]
% conversion to spherical geographic coordinate system method I
R = 6371;
lat1 = asin(P(3)/R); % lattitude of point P
lon1 = atan2(P(2),P(1)); % longitutde of point P
% conversion back to cartesian system for method I
P_converted1 = [R*cos(lon1) * cos(lat1); R*sin(lon1) * cos(lat1); R*sin(lat1)]
error1 = (abs(P-P_converted1)./P) * 100 % percentage error of two conversions
% conversion to spherical geographic coordinate system method II
R = 6371;
lat2 = acos(sqrt(P(1)^2 + P(2)^2)/R) % lattitude of point P
lon2 = atan2(P(2),P(1)); % longitutde of point P
% conversion back to cartesian system for method II
P_converted2 = [R*cos(lon2) * cos(lat2); R*sin(lon2) * cos(lat2); R*sin(lat2)]
error2 = (abs(P-P_converted2)./P) * 100 % percentage error of two conversions

Réponse acceptée

Jan
Jan le 26 Oct 2016
Modifié(e) : Jan le 26 Oct 2016
The precision is reduced by the weak definition of the radius R:
P = [3554.6 ; 1205.7 ; 5150.9]
norm(P)
% >> 6373.43427517692
R = 6371; % !!!
With a correct radius, the error vanishes:
P = [3554.6 ; 1205.7 ; 5150.9]
R = norm(P);
lat1 = asin(P(3)/R); % lattitude of point P
lon1 = atan2(P(2),P(1)); % longitutde of point P
P_converted1 = [R*cos(lon1) * cos(lat1); R*sin(lon1) * cos(lat1); R*sin(lat1)]
error1 = (abs(P-P_converted1)./P) * 100
error1 = [1.27932074181754e-014, 0, 0] and the same for error2.

Plus de réponses (0)

Catégories

En savoir plus sur Geographic Plots dans Help Center et File Exchange

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by