Performance Problem in Simulink (why is it slower than matlab?)

7 vues (au cours des 30 derniers jours)
Akbar
Akbar le 10 Avr 2018
Modifié(e) : Akbar le 12 Avr 2018
I have compared Solutions to the same ODE in matlab and simulink. Simulink took 7.6 sec. while ode15s in matlab took 1.4 sec. to solve. What is the reason for this time difference? FYI: I used the same number of time steps in both cases. And simulink model was run from matlab, using 'sim' function.
  1 commentaire
Akbar
Akbar le 12 Avr 2018
Matlab code:
for i = 1:100
[t{ind},X{ind}] = ode15s(func,0:.1:10,X0);
end
Simulink code:
for i = 1:100
simOut = sim(model_file,'SimulationMode','normal');
outputs = simOut.get('yout');
outI = outputs.get('X');
t{ind} = outI.Values.Time;
X{ind} = outI.Values.Data;
end

Connectez-vous pour commenter.

Réponses (1)

Steven Lord
Steven Lord le 10 Avr 2018
Which solver did you use when you simulated your system? Did you leave the selection up to Simulink?
The ode15s solver in MATLAB is a stiff solver while ode45 is not. So if your simulation used ode45, to compare apples and apples you'd want to compare that with solving the system in MATLAB using ode45 (or switch both to use a stiff solver.)
  1 commentaire
Akbar
Akbar le 12 Avr 2018
Modifié(e) : Akbar le 12 Avr 2018
In simulink I used: "VariableStepAuto". I have just tried ode15s on both (with the same stepsize: 0.1) and still got a significant difference in time. Apart from that, simulink and ode45 have failed to solve the System correctly, it deviated from the true solution.
ode15s: 0.8488
ode45: 0.088538
simulink (normal): 13.2582

Connectez-vous pour commenter.

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by