Ideal way to access data in a table?

Is there a "prefered" way to access data in a table?
T.var1(1);
T{1,var1};
T{1,1};

3 commentaires

Stephen23
Stephen23 le 17 Août 2018
Use whatever syntax is clearest for your code.
Code is read more times than it is written. Complex code is harder to understand and has more bugs. Debugging is going to use more time than any possible speed benefits of any one of those syntaxes (if any). Therefore your aim is to make your code as clear as possible. Which syntax is clearest depends on what you are doing in your algorithm: it would make no sense to muck around with column names if your algorithm fundamentally depends on indices, and it would make no sense to muck around with indices if your algorithm fundamentally depends on column names. Use whichever is best for the situation.
All of those syntaxes are "prefered", in different situations.
Peter Perkins
Peter Perkins le 24 Août 2018
+1 to Stephen, however, T{1,var1} would have to be T{1,'var1'}. Also, while I find T.var1(1) easier to follow than t{1,'var1'}, once you get to accessing the data in more than one variable in a table all at once, braces are the way to go: T{1,{'var1' 'var2'}}.
Walter Roberson
Walter Roberson le 24 Août 2018
If you are importing from a csv or xls or xlsx, then a question becomes which you trust to be more accurate as files change: column number, or column header.
Some "standard" formats (even if only unofficial standards) define information according to column; others define by column names.
If your users expect to be able to insert columns at arbitrary points as long as they keep the column headers the same for what is already there, then you should probably be using column name.

Connectez-vous pour commenter.

Réponses (0)

Catégories

Tags

Question posée :

le 17 Août 2018

Commenté :

le 24 Août 2018

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by