MATLAB Answers

MOD for optimization variable

18 views (last 30 days)
annazy on 22 Aug 2019
Commented: Matt J on 25 Aug 2019
I have to optimize matrix to obtain quantities that will be divisible by certain numbers. When I use MOD on numbers, it works fine, for example MOD(10,3)=1. However, when I try to create constraint that I want my optimization variable x to be divisible by let's say 3 MOD(x,3), I get an error
Undefined function 'mod' for input arguments of type 'optim.problemdef.OptimizationVariable'.
Is there anything I can do to solve this issue?
Thanks in advance.


Sign in to comment.

Accepted Answer

Matt J
Matt J on 24 Aug 2019
Edited: Matt J on 24 Aug 2019
No need to use constraints. Just declare x as an OptimizationExpression,
x=3*optimvar('z','Type', 'Integer','LowerBound',0)
x =
Now use x freely to build the objective and constraints as you did previously. E.g.,
x=3*optimvar('z','Type', 'integer','LowerBound',0);
The solver will solve for z, not x,
>> sol
sol =
struct with fields:
y: 1.0000
z: 2.0000
but you can easily convert the optimal z to a corresponding result for x.
>> x_optimal=evaluate(x,sol)
x_optimal =


Matt J
Matt J on 25 Aug 2019
annazy's comment moved here:
This is wonderful. What I actually need is this 'z', as I optimize quantities of products which must be divisible by number of products per cartoon. However this number varies depending on products. Also, I have multiple percentage constraints on quantities (not cartoons) which is why I can't focus on cartoons only, but in the end number of cartoons is what I need.
You are both amazing people, I hope one day I will be clever enough to help other lost souls like you do help me :)
Matt J
Matt J on 25 Aug 2019
I'm glad it's what you need but please Accept-click the answer if it addresses your question.

Sign in to comment.

More Answers (1)

Walter Roberson
Walter Roberson on 22 Aug 2019
Introduce an extra integer variable and constrain equality x-3*extra = 1


Show 1 older comment
Walter Roberson
Walter Roberson on 23 Aug 2019
For a definitive answer as to whether there is any way to make mod() work, you will need to open a support case with Mathworks. Perhaps they have an in-house implementation that they might be willing to let you experiment with; I do not know.
What I do know is that there is no mod() available for optimization variables in any released version.
"I can't influence on values of x with some random integers as I have other requirements to be met :( "
I suspect you do not understand the process.
Suppose that you have a value of x = 16 and you want to check whether mod(x,3)=1 . If so, then by definition, there must be some integer N (that is not necessarily positive) such that 3*N+1 = x . This is not a "random integer": for 16 it is satisfied only by N = 5, 3*5 + 1 = 16. Likewise, if there is no integer N such that 3*N+1 = x, then mod(x,3)=1 is not true -- for example, for x = 17, then there is no such integer N.
Therefore if you introduce an integer-constrained variable N into the process and put in the equality constraint 3*N+1 = x, or 1 = x - 3*N or x - 3*N = 1 then N will not be random: it will be the exact integer needed such that 3*N+1 = x. You would not use the value of N in the calculation of your objective: it is enough to know that the constraint was met that there is some integer N such that x - 3*N = 1 is true.
annazy on 24 Aug 2019
Wow, thank you a lot for such detailed answer and your patience. Honestly, this is my first experience with Matlab and I am a bit confused with its options. I used to solve simple optimization problems with Excel Solver, however due to the dimension of the matrix, in this case I cannot use Solver as it can't hadle such large size. I was forced to learn basic optimization tools in Matlab within a week :(
I understand the process, I just don't know how to create such Integer variable correctly. I only add new variables with numbers or create optimization variables for objective funtion. Is it supposed to be a new optimization variable? Something like N=optimvar('N','Type','integer')?
Thanks in advance, you're saving my life.
Walter Roberson
Walter Roberson on 24 Aug 2019
Yes, N=optimvar('N','Type','integer') is good.
If you have upper and/or lower bound on x then you can use it to figure out upper and lower bounds on N to make the optimization more efficient.

Sign in to comment.

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by