Replacing for loops with vectorization
18 vues (au cours des 30 derniers jours)
Afficher commentaires plus anciens
Kyle Baldwin
le 19 Fév 2021
Commenté : Kyle Baldwin
le 21 Fév 2021
Questions similar to this have been asked before, but I've struggled to understand the answers. I am looking to speed up my Matlab programs by avoiding for loops. I have seen the remark that Matlab is a high level programming language and so things like for loops shouldn't be necessary, but if anyone could help me figure out how to avoid them in my simple example I would very much appreciate it.
The following script simulates the motion of a pendulum quite well:
length=0.1;
g=9.81;
omega(1)=0;
theta(1)=2;
t(1)=0;
timeStep = 0.01;
t = t(1):timeStep:t(1)+(timeStep*9999);
for i=2:10000
omega(i) = omega(i-1) + (g/length)*sin(theta(i-1))*timeStep;
theta(i) = theta(i-1)+omega(i)*timeStep;
end
plot(t,theta);
xlabel('Time (s)');
ylabel('Theta (rad)');
I have figured out how to vectorize t, shown before the start of the for loop. The issue is that omega and theta are both part of two simultaneous equations, where the next value of theta needs to be calculated based on the previous value of omega, and the next value of omega needs to be calculated based on the previous value of theta.
Is it possible to do this to use vectorization instead of a for loop?
Thank you,
Kyle
P.S. This is for teaching, my students will appreciate anything that speeds up their work!
5 commentaires
KALYAN ACHARJYA
le 19 Fév 2021
Modifié(e) : KALYAN ACHARJYA
le 19 Fév 2021
@Stephen Cobeldick Finally I have confirmed in this case. Sir, thanks for your valuable advices.
Réponse acceptée
James Tursa
le 20 Fév 2021
Modifié(e) : James Tursa
le 20 Fév 2021
No, in general you cannot vectorize loops such as this. What you are doing in this particular loop is solving a 2nd order differential equation numerically. At each step, the derivative depends on the current state. Thus, you have to iterate through the time steps to integrate from state to state. Since you don't know all of these states ahead of time, you can't vectorize the results with some type of matrix calculation. You will need to have the loop as you are currently doing. Even if you were to call a function such as ode45( ) for this, there would still be iteration loops embedded in ode45( ) to calculate the result.
Plus de réponses (0)
Voir également
Community Treasure Hunt
Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!
Start Hunting!