best way to define a function inside a script

85 vues (au cours des 30 derniers jours)
Alessio
Alessio le 14 Sep 2011
Commenté : Steven Lord le 8 Avr 2024
Hi to everyone,
I'm currently searching the way to use functions inside a script, read documentation and so on..... I'm just an entry-level matlab user but i already spent too many hours searching in topics and documentations, without finding any answer about this. I think to have understood the difference between scripts and functions, but I'd like to know how can I define a function inside a script to use it several time into the script. I could define a function and save it as an m-file, and call it inside a script, but if my function has only few lines it's not so convenient... I would like to have only one m-file.
Many thanks in advance
Alessio
  3 commentaires
Pink_panther
Pink_panther le 7 Avr 2024
Modifié(e) : Pink_panther le 7 Avr 2024
Miracles in 2024, now you can place function (ANYwhere !!) inside a script M-file. Just tested thiss in 2024a.
^%%%%%
Each local function must begin with its own function definition statement and end with the end keyword. The functions can appear in any order and can be defined anywhere in the script. Before R2024a: Local functions in scripts must be defined at the end of the file, after the last line of script code.
Mathworks
Steven Lord
Steven Lord le 8 Avr 2024
You can place functions almost anywhere in scripts as of release R2024a as stated in the Release Notes. You can't define them inside conditional statements.

Connectez-vous pour commenter.

Réponse acceptée

Fangjun Jiang
Fangjun Jiang le 14 Sep 2011
If the function is relatively small and easy, I think you can use anonymous function. Search for anonymous function in documentation for details. For example:
a=1;
b=2;
f=@(x) x/2;
c=f(a)
d=f(b)
Or inline function John mentioned above.
g=inline('x/2');
e=g(a)
  4 commentaires
Ahmed Hafez
Ahmed Hafez le 24 Mar 2019
I think you are right Nora
I already used it and it works
Thanks
Walter Roberson
Walter Roberson le 24 Mar 2019
R2016b added the possibility of functions inside scripts. The limitations are:
  1. The function name cannot be the same as the script name
  2. Each function must have a matching end line
  3. The functions must be after the script portion.

Connectez-vous pour commenter.

Plus de réponses (4)

Rodrigo Pereira
Rodrigo Pereira le 14 Nov 2017
I know this is old, but it has been viewed quite recently, so this answer may be useful.
Apparently you can do it since R2016b - perhaps Fangjun Jiang was able to wear them down? :)

John D'Errico
John D'Errico le 14 Sep 2011
The BEST way? There is NO way to define a function inside a script, unless you are talking about an anonymous function or an inline function.
It is best if you learn to avoid scripts anyway. Scripts lead you to bad habits in programming. They convince you to do things like clear at the beginning. Learn to use functions, where there is no need to clear your workspace when you start!!!
  2 commentaires
Alessio
Alessio le 14 Sep 2011
I would to accept your answer too but I realized it's not possible.. thank you too
Andrew Frane
Andrew Frane le 28 Mar 2021
Modifié(e) : Andrew Frane le 28 Mar 2021
There's a time and place for scripts, and a time and place for functions.

Connectez-vous pour commenter.


Alessio
Alessio le 14 Sep 2011
Many thanks guys, you perfectly understood my problem and actually the anonymous function is what I was searching for.... but it seems to be usable only within the command line, not in the script, is it right? and about function_handle, is it the solution for using an aanonymous_function in the script? I'm really sorry for my confusion...
To D'Errico: are you meaning that it's better to use a function m-file as a main() function in C?
  2 commentaires
Fangjun Jiang
Fangjun Jiang le 14 Sep 2011
It can be used in the script. Save the code in my answer to a script and you can run it.
Sean de Wolski
Sean de Wolski le 14 Sep 2011
Yes. In theory, you never need scripts, you just have a driver function that either takes a few inputs or is hardwired to create what you need and return it.
Personally, however, I usually use a driver script with many cells in cell mode that calls a bunch of functions. I find it's easier to debug these.

Connectez-vous pour commenter.


Li Klein
Li Klein le 11 Oct 2018
Hey everyone... I came across this super old question while looking for something completely different. To me it sounds like Alessio was actually looking for something like this: Matlab-Function-Types
You'll find the descriptions of all the different MATLAB function types in the provided link.
I'll leave it here in case this question ever comes up for another (new) user.
  1 commentaire
John D'Errico
John D'Errico le 8 Mar 2020
MATLAB has evolved considerably since this question was asked. Yes, there are now more ways to define a function. And you can now indeed put functions inside scripts. But it is almost 10 years since the question was asked.

Connectez-vous pour commenter.

Catégories

En savoir plus sur Logical dans Help Center et File Exchange

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by