Effacer les filtres
Effacer les filtres

Interpolating Data in 2D Mesh or Surf Plot?

19 vues (au cours des 30 derniers jours)
Sees
Sees le 13 Déc 2022
Modifié(e) : William Rose le 13 Déc 2022
Hello dear Matlab Community!
I'm struggling with interpolating data to refine the resolution for a mesh and/or surf plot. I've tried using interp2, datagrid and scatteredinterpolant however none of them seemed to work with the inputs I gave them. I want the 0 values of my z coordinates to be interpolated and also want a higher resolution such as described in the interp2 documentation (Link)
Here's an example as a dataset. I also attached the .csv files
Thank you in advance!
These are my X-Coordinates:
The Y-Coordinates:
The Z-Coordinates
  1 commentaire
Star Strider
Star Strider le 13 Déc 2022
It would help to have your code to understand what you did.
What results did you get?
What results do you want?

Connectez-vous pour commenter.

Réponses (1)

William Rose
William Rose le 13 Déc 2022
Modifié(e) : William Rose le 13 Déc 2022
[edit: I hit Submit belfore I was done]
You say you want to interpolate z values at the points where z=0, and you want a finer mesh.
You have too few non-zero z values for interpolation to work reliably. The grid has 102 positions, and you have only 21 non-zero values. All the boundary points are unknown. See plot below. It shows the X,Y locations of the known and unknown (Z=0) points.
X=load('X_Cords.csv'); Y=load('Y_Cords.csv'); Z=load('Z_Cords.csv');
plot(X(abs(Z)>0),Y(abs(Z)>0),'r*',X(Z==0),Y(Z==0),'bo')
xlabel('X'); ylabel('Y')
legend('Known','Unknown','Location','southwest')
You are mostly extrapolating, not interpolating. You need more known points to do interpolation with any confidence. Points on the boundary are especially valuable, since with them, you will be interpolating, and not extrapolating.
Let's add query points to the plot above: locations on a regular grid, where we want to estimate the Z value. We will create an array of query points with the same dimensions as the initial arrays. The query points, at which we want to estimate Z, are shown in green below.
Xq=X; Yq=repmat([0:-0.03:-0.15]',1,17);
plot(X(abs(Z)>0),Y(abs(Z)>0),'r*',X(Z==0),Y(Z==0),'bo',Xq,Yq,'gx')
xlabel('X'); ylabel('Y')
legend('Known','Unknown','Query','Location','southwest')
Let's discard the locaitons where Z=0 and then try to interpolate.
Xnz=X(abs(Z)>0); Ynz=Y(abs(Z)>0); Znz=Z(abs(Z)>0);
We can't use interp2(), since the known data are not on a regular grid. We can use scatteredInterpolant() instead. The arrays must be reshaped to columns for scatteredInterpolant().
Xnz=reshape(Xnz,[],1); Ynz=reshape(Ynz,[],1); Znz=reshape(Znz,[],1);
F=scatteredInterpolant(Xnz,Ynz,Znz);
Zq=F(Xq,Yq);
stem3(Xq,Yq,Zq,'bo'); xlabel('X'); ylabel('Y'); zlabel('Z')
hold on
stem3(Xnz,Ynz,Znz,'r*');
The plot includes vertical stems from the z=0 plane. If you run it in Matlab, you can spin it around in 3D, using the 3D rotate handle in the plot window, and see if you like it. I would never use results like this, since it is almost pure extrapolation.
  3 commentaires
Sees
Sees le 13 Déc 2022
@William Rose First of all thank you very much for your fast and constructive reply and I'm terribly sorry for the formatting mistake. I should have known better.
I forgot to add something that would change the approach you took. I said I want to interpolate all zero values, that's not true. The boundary values should stay zero. As I know of the importance of boundary conditions for such calculations I should have thought about that. May I ask again how you would proceed with this new information? :/
In addition. The interpolated Values are only used for presentation purposes and are more or less just a "gimmick" I wanted to add to my calculations for easier visual understanding.
Thank you!
William Rose
William Rose le 13 Déc 2022
Modifié(e) : William Rose le 13 Déc 2022
[Edit: Replace Z with Zo in lines to remove Zo=-99 points. Attach csv files. Add plots.]
Enter a value of Z=-99 at the unknown points in Excel spreadsheet. Keep values of Z=0, where zero is known. Save the spreadsheet arrays in CSV files as before. In your script, read in the data from the files, into arrays Xo,Yo,Zo.
Xo=load('X_Cords.csv');
Yo=load('Y_Cords.csv');
Zo=load('Z_Cords.csv');
etc. Make vectors X, Y, Z which do not have the Z=-99 points, like we did above.
X=reshape(Xo(Zo~=-99),[],1);
Y=reshape(Yo(Zo~=-99),[],1);
Z=reshape(Zo(Zo~=-99),[],1);
Find the interpolating function:
F=scatteredInterpolant(X,Y,Z);
Warning: Duplicate data points have been detected and removed - corresponding values have been averaged.
Make grids of query points Xq, Yq, with meshgrid() or however you want.
[Xq,Yq]=meshgrid(0:.215:4.3,0:-.02:-.16);
Then interpolate Z at the query points:
Zq=F(Xq,Yq);
In my earlier answer, I did not interpolate values at the original unknown points. If it is important to you to estimate Z at those points, then do it, using Xo and Yo as query points
Zo=F(Xo,Yo);
Display results graphically:
plot(X,Y,'r*',Xq,Yq,'bo')
xlabel('X'); ylabel('Y')
legend('Known','Query','Location','southwest')
figure
stem3(Xq,Yq,Zq,'bo'); hold on; stem3(X,Y,Z,'r*');
xlabel('X'); ylabel('Y'); zlabel('Z')
You have repeated points at X=0,Y=0 and repeated points at X=4.3,Y=0.

Connectez-vous pour commenter.

Catégories

En savoir plus sur 2-D and 3-D Plots dans Help Center et File Exchange

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by