Disable automatic conversion to reals

6 vues (au cours des 30 derniers jours)
Kevin le 2 Août 2018
Is there a way to disable the automatic conversion of a complex variable with zero imaginary component into a purely real variable?
>> x = complex(zeros(2,2)) % complex
x =
0.0000 + 0.0000i 0.0000 + 0.0000i
0.0000 + 0.0000i 0.0000 + 0.0000i
>> x(2,1) = -1 % magically becomes real
x =
0 0
-1 0
This is bothering me because:
  1. It differs from the behavior of gpuArrays, for which subsref and subsasgn preserve complexity.
  2. It triggers an unnecessary memory copy (and then again when I eventually store a complex value into the matrix).
  3. This is not playing well with MEX routines that expect the arguments to have the same datatype.
To that last point, consider the following:
>> x = complex(randn(4,100), randn(4,100)); % complex
>> y = x .* max(0,abs(x)-1); % also complex
>> for ii = 1:100
z = mymexfunc(x(:,ii), y(:,ii)) % sometimes not complex
fprintf('Error on iter %d\n',ii);
Error on iter 44
Error on iter 62
I thought it was safe to assume that a subscripted reference from a complex array would yield a complex array, but it turns out I was wrong.
Our C/C++ developer is pretty busy these days, so before I go bother her about adding mixed-complexity support to the MEX routines, I am wondering:
  1. Is there an undocumented feature flag I can disable? Something like feature('auto_convert_reals',0) would be great.
  2. Are there alternatives to parenthetical indexing that do preserve complexity?
  2 commentaires
Walter Roberson
Walter Roberson le 2 Août 2018
Which MATLAB release? R2017b changed how complex values are stored.
Kevin le 2 Août 2018

Connectez-vous pour commenter.

Réponse acceptée

Edric Ellis
Edric Ellis le 2 Août 2018
Modifié(e) : Edric Ellis le 2 Août 2018
MATLAB's behaviour has always been to drop the imaginary part on indexing operations (where it is all zero!). gpuArray is somewhat incompatible with standard MATLAB behaviour in this regard - this was a deliberate choice to improve performance of gpuArray indexing (since the very beginning, gpuArray has used interleaved-complex format).
Anyway, probably your best bet is to preprocess your MEX arguments using a simple MATLAB wrapper, something like this:
function varargout = matchComplexity(varargin)
% Require precisely as many outputs as inputs.
nargoutchk(nargin, nargin);
varargout = varargin;
% Check which are stored as real
isReal = cellfun(@isreal, varargout);
% If not all arrays stored as real, complexify those that are real
if ~all(isReal)
varargout(isReal) = cellfun(@complex, varargout(isReal), ...
'UniformOutput', false);
Clearly, you'll want to apply this only to your data arguments that are expected to match in complexity.
  1 commentaire
Kevin le 2 Août 2018
Just out of curiosity: now that complex arrays in host memory also use the interleaved format, are there any plans to change this behavior in future releases?

Connectez-vous pour commenter.

Plus de réponses (2)

James Mentz
James Mentz le 28 Jan 2019
Sorry, this is a bug, not a feature. You can have an entire array of complex number and writing a single indexed value with a number where the imaginary part = 0 will destroy all of the complex information in the entire array.
If Matlab is going to do this we need a new immutable array data type where once it's declared complex it stays complex.
I had to work around this by checking EVER value going into the array and if the imaginary part is zero I add (realmin('single') * 1i) to each entry, this doing every bit as much checking as Matlab does to make these values fragil, with the added downsize of dithering my data by realmin.
  1 commentaire
Rik le 28 Jan 2019
The point is not that this behavior occurs when imag(z_input)==0, but when all imaginary parts of the resulting array are zero. I would still consider it a bug, but it is less dramatic than your post seems to suggest.
No information is lost, only the data type changes.

Connectez-vous pour commenter.

Jim Svensson
Jim Svensson le 1 Sep 2022
Modifié(e) : Jim Svensson le 1 Sep 2022
I agree that Matlab's way of automatically dropping imaginary part when zero is stupid, very annyoing and it causes extra problems in many cases. I wish it could be disabled.


En savoir plus sur Logical dans Help Center et File Exchange




Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by