common tangent of two curves with vpasolve.
4 vues (au cours des 30 derniers jours)
Afficher commentaires plus anciens
muhsin ider
le 8 Juin 2020
Commenté : muhsin ider
le 12 Juin 2020
The following code finds common tangents of fx and gx by symbolic expressions. I used first "solve" but sometimes it can not find all the roots of the denk1 and denk2 which are derived from common tangent geometry. vpasolve finds a pair of x,y but not both. I appreciate any help or suggestions.
best wishes,
clc, clear all, close all
disp([' (t) a b']);
R=8.314 ;%j/mol K;
O1=-15000;
O2=0; %j/mol K;
for t=1300:50:1350
syms x fx gx ek m(x) y1(x) a b y2(x) f(x) g(x) fu(x) gu(x)
syms denk1 denk2 denk3 p yx
f(x)=R*t*((x*log(x))+((1-x)*log(1-x)))+O1*(x-x^2);
g(x)=x*(12000-10*t)+((1-x)*(8000-10*t))+R*t*((x*log(x))+((1-x)*log(1-x)));
fu(x)=diff(f(x),x);%1. differential
gu(x)=diff(g(x),x);%2.differential
denk1=(((g(b)-f(a))/(b-a))==(fu(a)));
denk2=(fu(a)==gu(b));
%[a b]=solve(denk1,denk2,a,b);
%[kola kolb] = vpasolve([denk1 denk2],[a b],[0.2;.99991])
[Sola Solb] = vpasolve([denk1 denk2],[a b],[0.1; 0.3]);
a=Sola;
b=Solb;
disp([t,a,b])
x=0:0.01:1;
plot(x ,f(x),'r-',x ,g(x),'-b')
hold on
p = linspace(a,b);
%y=mx+n graph of common tangent line between a and b
yx=((fu(a))*(p-a))+f(a);
plot(p,yx, 'm-')
pause(2)
hold off
figure
end
2 commentaires
darova
le 12 Juin 2020
Here the results i got from your code
Look good. What is your question again?
Réponse acceptée
Bjorn Gustavsson
le 12 Juin 2020
In your code you gove starting-points for the variable you search for. Perhaps vpasolve doesn't bother to look for all solutions of your equation (in case they are too complex one solution might be considered good enough). Try to look for a second solution starting from another point (~0.8 and 0.9). If that gives you a second solution you've found the second solution. I've not looked at your equations to know how many solutions you should have...
HTH
7 commentaires
Bjorn Gustavsson
le 12 Juin 2020
That is most likely a design-choise by Mathworks. If, for example, vpasolve were to try to return all solutions of equations there might be problems when you try to solve equations with infinitely many solutions. Then there would need to be some arbitrary cut-off when the number of solutions will be considered "enough". Perhaps Mathworks then made the choise that one solution is enough.
Plus de réponses (0)
Voir également
Catégories
En savoir plus sur Loops and Conditional Statements dans Help Center et File Exchange
Community Treasure Hunt
Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!
Start Hunting!